My php menu now validates and my index does not, why?

New issue:

Index.php dose not validate. menu.php validates after adding in header and body information. Very confused as to what the problem now is?

Index page is: www.robinsden.110mb.com/index.php

and the validated menu page is:

www.robinsden.110mb.com/menu.php

As far as I know it's not so much that the page was not valid markup but that my menu that I am trying to refer to had the header and other information in it, so I have removed all that information from my menu.php file and now my index.php page validates fine but my menu.php dose not obviously.

I am really getting stump on how to resolve my issue? Just can't seem to get my menu to display correctly. Why?

The code is written so it works with anchor tags, change:

HTML Code:

---

My Hobbies

---

to

HTML Code:

---

<a href="#">My Hobbies</a>

---

and

HTML Code:

---

Services

---

to

HTML Code:

---

<a href="#">Services</a>

---

Good luck!